14 comments (0 hidden)

Wholesome boss and friend huuhh
this manga make me smile
Should “wholesome” be added as a tag option? Cause this one totally justifies it!
-2
>>1095536 @ Glovelove
Happy sex is different from wholesome.
Wholesome would be considered more descriptive of the entire work, not just one of the acts. For instance, you could conceivably have a netorare plot that ended in happy sex, but that wouldn’t be considered a wholesome story.
-2
Shirou
And how is that supposed to be a fetish, at all? We won't add tags that a: are already covered for the most part by existing ones and b: aren't actual fetishes people would use to fap to.
>>1095541 @ Gobo-Gobo
Sounds like a wholesome ending, and would probably fail the presence requirement for Happy Sex if it is only the ending.

If you want it to be a separate tag to even be considered in the first place we'd need a more objective definition of what is and isn't wholesome, and how it would clearly set itself apart from Happy Sex pretty much being the same thing already. Tags that rely on "well I think it was wholesome" are going to be little more than kindling for edit wars, tags that have semi-objective criteria like Netorare, Ugly Bastard and Happy Sex already suffer from this to an extend and we're not going to make that problem larger.
i usually don't write comments on here but i had to write one to this one because this one here is good for soul the things i like about this
1-the old guy here is not an old and ugly bastard who tries to stole the girl he is an old and wise sage like guy who is great to help mc hiding in the shadows i love that kind of characters in everywhere.
2-the playboy friend here is not some steal-your girl bastard who supposed to be your friend but back stabs you without shame he is actually happy for his friend and is a decent enough guy who knows bro's before hoes (i mean don't betray your friendship just for pussy it is soooo not worth it)
3-the woman here is genuinely attached to the mc and this is a real woman and human being for me, the feelings is about connection not about other shallow things.
as you can already figure, there is nothing i hate more than netorare and if anyone wants to take this as kink shaming so be it, i can't get a hard on or jerk of when one person suffer in the corner especially from betrayal and humiliation and before you start with don't self-insert as the one who get NTR'd of course i don't self insert myself as the guy but if i self insert as the stoler thief son of the bitch i start to hate and loath myself, it is not about self insertment it is about i can't take pleasure from someone who doesn't deserve betrayal and humiliation and is completely innocent, also the plot in most ntr is too unrealastic to the point of it just plain cruelty and nothing more, the only time i wasn't aware the blacklist thing and forgot to check tags and read a ntr the only thing i wanted to do was going there pulling the poor guy to his feets then going to the cheating whore(s) and the loser who thinks he has a big one taking the bitches and make them serve the poor guy and ripping the penis of the evil bastard out of his crotch to show how DEADLY serious i am then after the poor guy done with his jon taking him to drink his pain and later find a real woman who will really love him, i know that this is just fiction but incredibly evil one and the hatred i felt the first time i read was something i couldn't hold it in and that hatred still burns strong (by the way i couldn't finish the damned thing i could read only about roughly 10 page after that i immediately created an account and banned all the genres i hate)
>>1095551 @ Glovelove
I think anything that doesn't cause physical or emotional pain to the characters would be a good baseline.
>>1218378 @ SpikeSpiegel
Too common, might as well start having tags for "vaginal sex" and "human" at that point
>>1218418 @ Glovelove
It is the standard style of lovemaking.
>>1218419 @ SpikeSpiegel
That's the point, tags are there to help people find or filter things that aren't the standard.
>>1218440 @ SpikeSpiegel
ok let me rephrase this: on E-hentai they decided that was the point of tags, and moderation here agreed with that. You're allowed to disagree with it but this is the mentality kept in mind when we decide if new tags should be added.

Happy Sex is already an exception to that in how excessively broad Shirou wanted it to be, and we really don't need multiple exceptions cover pretty much the same thing.

Linking: To prevent spam, all links are stripped out of your comment.

You can link internally to galleries, users, tags, etc. by typing an identifier (consisting of one letter and a number) between brackets. To quickly find and select tags and galleries to link to, use the searchfield to insert them into your post.

Examples:
  • Reply to a post: eg. [C5]
  • Link to a tag: eg. [T187]
  • Link to a gallery: eg. [G54]
  • Link to an image: eg. [G54#2]
  • Link to a user: eg. [U521]
  • Link to a contribution: eg. [S128]
  • Link to a forum post: eg. [P15]

Popular right now